Quote:
Originally posted by Tyrone Slothrop
I don't care so much about the hypocrisy. Let's all just forget the easy talk about "small government" and pay attention to what they're doing. Massive spending, deficits, and tax cuts for the rich.
One, it wouldn't be "starting" to tax us if we returned to paying the same taxes we paid a few years ago. Two, the American people would rather pay the taxes and get the benefits. If there was political support for doing what you describe, we wouldn't have these deficits. It's political suicide.
|
Ty, how many times can it be explained to you that the tax cuts are not "for" the rich. Yes, they give the rich more than they do the poor. But saying they're "for" the rich is just dead wrong. Do you really believe the GOP is actively engaged in economic class warfare? Of course not - you've admitted they're not. Yet you still use that Berkleyish, Mooreish phrase, "for the rich," implying active GOP attacks on the poor. I suggest in the future you use, "tax cuts which give more money to the rich than the poor."
But then that would force you to admit the tax cuts are neutral, wouldn't it?
I don't agree that the American people would prefer to be taxed and provided benefits by the govt over not being taxed and finding the benefits for themselves. If we put that to a referendum, I think the Dems, and their social-engineering left wing, would get trounced in the vote.
People will always take cash in hand over promises of future benefits which are likely to be cut. We don't have such referendums because, even the GOP would be uncomfortable with the extent to which people would vote to slash taxes and programs.
Bush's SS plan didn't work because it was byzantine and retirees were frightened because they don't like risk and things they don't understand.
BUT, if it were repackaged as a simple choice to opt out of SS, everyone with a wherewithall to do so, or even the ability to reasonably risk doing so, would leave SS. That vote would show who wants a handout pretty damned quickly.
All this said, sadly, I must agree with Slave. In the end, far too many Americans want both low taxes and handouts, and that'll always cripple any true tax and govt reform efforts. We're too fucking addicted to the notion of Uncle Sam bailing us out.