| ThurgreedMarshall |
04-03-2003 01:34 PM |
I wish I was a little bit taller....I wish I was a baller
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore
So, when someone who has not dabbled in classical tries it, it's stealing? When blues spread, it's been misappropriated?
|
Yes. Of course. That's exactly what I'm implying.
Actually, I was trying to ask you why you thought there was such a big difference between someone taking a style, copying it and holding themselves out like they're some huge genius and lifting a recognizable line from a recognizable song. But I no longer care.
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore
(BTW, I didn't even know that the song in question was rap - so, to your disappointment, my comment wasn't a racial thing.)
|
Sometimes, to your disappointment, you really come off as an asshole. Initially, I was kidding with you. When is the last time you saw me put a smiley into a post? Jesus Christ. I was messing with you because we always have this argument.
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore
You're taking this way too seriously.
|
Actually, after the initial joke, I was trying to have a normal discussion with you. Clearly that's impossible.
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore I simply meant that to copy, word-for-word, someone else's lyrics and drop them into your own song seems plagiaristic to me. Sampling seems different, as it is clear what's going on. Think most of the listeners to your song know who Buffalo Springfield was?
|
I know what you meant. And the plagiarism accusation is ridiculous. As I said, the line was chosen because it is so recognizable. I think any implication that he was trying to pretend that he made it up is stupid. I'm sure most of his listeners have no idea who Buffalo Springfield was. But I'm even more sure that they have all heard that song at one point or another.
Thurgreed(whatever)Marshall
|