| The Larry Davis Experience |
09-29-2004 02:00 PM |
James Fallows on the debates
Quote:
Originally posted by sgtclub
Kerry is too vulnerable in this debate.
The debates are less about substance and more about composure. Kerry never smiles, he just makes that face where he looks like he's about to take a shit. He just doesn't look comfortable. Bush is loosey goosey, almost goofey at times. But he smiles and looks in control. So even if Kerry whips him substantively, the debate will still be viewed as very close because Bush will look control.
|
Yesterday I'd probably have agreed with you, but last night I saw that Fallows guy do what I presume is a similar presentation to the one Gatti saw, including some clips from W's 94 TX debates and Kerry's '96 Senate debates.
Kerry is just not the same guy in a debate format, and God help me I have no idea why Debate Kerry isn't doing the campaigning while Stump Kerry is kidnapped and held at an undisclosed location until December. It's not that he's such a great communicator, but he makes his points quickly and cleanly, and puts some emotion behind it. Far cry from his normal meanderings. Also he's willing to joke a little. Weld was certainly the more entertaining of the two, but Kerry was not the stiff that we see in the news clips.
The Bush team was smart to keep Kerry from being able to move around and ask questions directly of Bush, since it may cause Debate Kerry to yield the floor back to Stump Kerry. If that happens, it will be lights out. Bush is definitely in control as a debater, and in fact looked better in 94 than I even remember from the '00 debates with Gore. What sells with Bush is exactly what comes through in the debate: "I may not know spit about arguing with this dandified Frenchman, but I know what I know, and what I know is that I'm the President and we're taking the fight to the terrorists."
It's going to be weird to watch these debates and know that what matters is not what the men are saying but rather is how they come across to some undecided (and presumably ill-informed) voter in Wisconsin/Ohio/Florida/insert name of state actually in play.
|