| ThurgreedMarshall |
07-15-2003 05:17 PM |
Continuation of my saga from a long time ago (spring 2001)
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore
I wasn't defending the use of the word "kike" at all, except to maybe give ME some credit and think that his use of it was a (bad) way to say "stop with the stereotyping shit". I think ME knows he went too far in anger.
|
I understood what he was trying to do. "You were stereotyping, so I'll take it one step further."
Quote:
Originally posted by bilmore
I just think that it's PC as hell for everyone else to jump him without any acknowledgement that the JJLC shit could be (and, as it turns out, was) very offensive to someone else. If you go back and read those particular posts and try to imagine the viewpoint of some true believer, you have to realize that, even though the popular stereotype of the fundamentalist christians is fun and all, it's not true for most, and it's offensive. We can't just be careful to avoid offending popular groups. (Oh, lord, I said that Jews were popular. Somebody's gonna be pissed.)
|
I don't think it's all that PC. I think you're ignoring both posters' tone. I think JJLC's tone wasn't even close to serious (and I had to click them all to take Jesus off mute (there's a board motto if I've ever heard one) to go back and read them). Making fun of a belief system (whether you say, "people who believe everything they read in the Bible are wingnuts" or "people who think they have been reincarnated are wackadoo") is very much different from calling someone a kike. Now, yez, it's true that someone who is deeply religious will be offended by this; and that is not in question. But the fact that the knee jerk reaction to someone poking fun of your beliefs is to label them with a slur is problematic.
What I find more interesting is that you didn't say anything about JJLC's offensive posts (or the kike thing) until you saw a PC issue to jump on. Advocating an open market of ideas is one thing, but this just seems strange to me.
Thurgreed(and no, I'm not calling you a racist)Marshall
|