Quote:
Originally posted by Hank Chinaski
Sebastian might have stretched a little, but the underlying point is well-taken. If I listed my 5 favorite bands there wouldn't be any "extras" in them. no horns no keyboards. Certainly there have been songs where bands have effectively used each, but overall I think not. Of course he limited it to punkish rock. He doesn't mean soul. i mean you guy's will be challenging him on Jazz bands next.
|
Actually, he did not limit it to "punkish rock." His statement said "bands." You cannot even read a "punkish rock" limitation into his statement since it was made in the context of describing the Rolling Stones, who are not "punkish" rock. They are much more based in R&B, and to argue that no R&B-based band has ever used horns effectively is, as I noted before, remarkable even for Sebastian.
