Quote:
Originally posted by dc_chef
spoiler
What is it with those shows (Rockstar is another example) with the bizarre criticism? One person stepped it up too little, one person stepped it up too much, cohesiveness of colors? The hell? Someone discussed the fact that people would buy the clothes, but that was like a throw away comment. With the rest of the stuff, I was expecting something like, well, we really liked your collection, but the way that you brushed your teeth before the show really irked me...
|
I don't think the criticism was bizarre. I thought it was actually correct. A collection is judged artistically, not just on how well it will sell. That's just one factor. I think all of the clothes shown last night would sell. However, I actually agreed with the judges as to who should win (although I was very pissed about it). Unfortunately Michael does not do well (yet) when he is operating without a clear structure. The challenges that he won were very structured. He falls back on old habits when he is given total creative freedom. Oh well, he is beloved by America, is dating Brandy and everyone knows it is just a matter of time before he becomes a great designer, so I don't feel too bad for him.
