Forums

[Tyrone Slothrop]

Originally posted by Not Me
I think some people are; they are just not claiming that he agreed with the plan. They are claiming he heard these conversations and then promptly ended his association with the group.

Cite, please. That's not in the CNN article.

As Bilmore indicated, no one can remember a cub scout meeting when they are 5 years old. However, grown men, indeed decorated vietnam war veterans turned anti-war activists, would be far more likely to remember a meeting in which someone said "hey lets kill US Senators" and which prompted him to resign from the group.

Perhaps so, if he heard it.

He claimed he remembered resigning from the group in July (which was a few months before the meeting). It is just that he forgot attending the November meeting. Seems like he can remember things he wants to "remember" that happened 30 years ago.

No doubt he's been shown documents relating to the July meeting recently, and they refreshed his recollection.

So when I ask you "cite please" you tell me to research it myself but I am supposed to do your research for you?

Why don't you just tell me what you think I said before that I'm contradicting now? I had a law school professor who played "Guess What I'm Thinking?" too, and it wasn't fun then, either.

Ok, see now neither one of us has to find your old posts. You are clearly implying something fishy about Bush's national guard service right here and now.

I was suggesting that he didn't show up for service in Alabama. Don't we all know this?

It is my understanding that all the records have been released and the records show he missed some weekends but made them up (which apparently is commonplace in the guard). If you are saying they haven't released all the records, then cite please.

They say they have released other people. According to stuff posted (I believe) on Kevin Drum's old blog, http://www.calpundit.com, one would expect there to be other sorts of records in the ordinary course that haven't been released.