Offering constructive criticism to the social cripples in our midst since early 2005.

[sgtclub]

Originally posted by Tyrone Slothrop
This idea that the Geneva Conventions were intended to create a class of people ("enemy combatants") who would be unprotected is historically flimsy. And other things that our military has done to evade the Geneva Conventions and other protections -- e.g., a signed Presidential letter to give military personnel a necessity defense to any prosecution -- are flimsier still.

I'm not a Geneva Convention scholar, and in fact have never read it, but I don't think it creates the enemy combatant classification. I think it defines a class of people who are entitled to the protections, but the Gitmo prisoners fall outside that definition. So I don't think you have your facts straight.

Then again, I may be wrong.